Typically, bag filters are the ideal solution for filtering high volumes of liquid. However, there are other considerations when choosing between cartridge filters and bag filters, including the application, the level of contaminant and/or particle removal needed, and ongoing costs and maintenance.
In this blog, we’ll explore why bag filters are often deemed best for high-flow applications, whether this is always the case, the key factors to consider when choosing between cartridge and bag filters, and what kind of filter is best for your application.
First, let’s clarify what we mean by bag filters, cartridge filters and flow rates.
Bag filters are fabric filters that sit inside a bag filter housing. As liquid passes through the system, the bag filter traps unwanted particles inside. They effectively remove coarser particles and are well suited to high-flow applications.
Cartridges also sit within a filter housing, capturing unwanted particles on the surface or inside the filter. Different types of cartridge filters deal with different filtration needs. Generally, cartridge filters are best suited to fine, precise filtration.
Flow rate refers to the volume of liquid being passed through the system over a period of time. We measure this in litres per minute (LPM). Flow rate is important because a filtration system that can’t handle the flow rate may lose efficiency and/or require more regular maintenance.
Why Are Bag Filters Considered Best for High-Flow Applications?
Bag filters are considered best for high-flow applications where particle levels and dirt loading are high.
Generally speaking, bag filters can handle larger volumes of liquid than cartridge filters. A single filter bag can often process the same flow rate as a multi-cartridge filter system. With high dirt-holding capacity and low pressure drop, bag filters effectively separate solids from liquids. When they have reached capacity, they are quickly and easily replaced, meaning minimal operational interruption.
However, bag filters are not usually able to filter liquids to the extent that cartridges can.
Most bag filters can’t remove bacteria or dissolved chemicals, and that makes them unsuitable for certain applications.
So, let’s explore some other key considerations when choosing a filter for high-flow applications.
Key Factors to Consider When Choosing Between Cartridge and Bag Filters
The Application
Some industries have the option to use either bag or cartridge filters, and some use a combination of both. Typically, though, bag filters are used in cosmetics manufacturing, the paints and coatings industry, fuel reconditioning, and chemical processing. Filter cartridges are used in dairy, food service, engineering, cosmetics, wine and beer production, and residential drinking water systems.
The application is crucial because this will dictate the level of filtration needed.
Level of Filtration
Level of filtration is the degree to which a filter removes particles from a liquid, and this varies from one application to another.
For example, in paints and coatings, bag filters are able to remove solid particles and lumps effectively, and do so at a high flow rate. Drinking water filtration, though, requires more thorough filtration, and so you’d opt for cartridge filters.
Whatever type of filter you’re using, it will be rated by the size of particles it removes. This is measured in microns, and one micron is a thousandth of a millimetre. The lower the micron rating, the finer the filtration.
Bag filters typically cover coarser ratings, making them best suited to removing larger particles. Cartridge filters can achieve finer ratings, including below 1 micron, although some high-efficiency bags can also reach this level.
You’ll find the micron rating for each of our filters in its product description or downloadable datasheet.
Operating Costs and Maintenance
Not all filter bags are suitable for reuse. However, our Spectrum bags can be cleaned and reused multiple times, making them a more cost-effective option. It’s also simple to remove and replace the filter bags within the bag filter housing.
Some cartridge filters can be washed and reused, depending on the type, although removal can be more labour-intensive, particularly in multi-cartridge housings.
Bag filters offer a lower upfront cost and generally require less floor space as single filter bags can handle high flow rates. As a larger housing or even multiple cartridges may be required to filter the same flow rate, cartridge filtration solutions are generally more expensive. However, in applications with lower contaminant levels, cartridges can have a long service life, which may reduce long-term costs.
Combined Bag and Cartridge Filtration Solutions
Bag filters are highly effective as a first stage of filtration to remove bulk solids. If finer filtration is then required, you might consider a multi-stage solution that combines bag filters and cartridge filters.
The bag filter is used initially to remove larger particles in a high-flow application, before the liquid is passed through cartridge filters to remove finer particles.
There are a number of advantages to this solution. Pre-filtration can prevent clogging in cartridge filters, extending cartridge lifespan and resulting in fewer changeouts. It can also reduce overall costs as the filter bags will be taking on the heavier load and are cheaper to replace.
However, this solution does not solve the flow rate issue entirely, as you may still require a multi-cartridge housing to cope with high-flow applications.
It’s also important to emphasise that not all filter bags are made equal. The Spectrum Premium Bag, for instance, has a multi-layer microfibre design, giving it a micron rating of 0.5 to 25 microns. Depending on flow rate and application, this may work as a stand-alone solution.
Which Filter Is Right for Your System?
Selecting the right filter for your system depends on the application and the level of filtration required. These, as well as cost and maintenance considerations, will generally lead you towards either a bag filter or a cartridge filter.
For high-flow applications, a bag filter is usually the preference. However, if a cartridge filter better meets your application and filtration level requirements, then a larger or multi-cartridge housing system can meet your needs and still handle high flow rates.
Alternatively, you might consider a combined bag and cartridge multi-stage filtration solution.
We provide useful graphs on our product datasheets that show micron ratings and flow rates for each filter. Please get in touch with our team and we’ll be happy to advise you on the right filter for your specific filtration and flow rate requirements.





